Can You Write a Better Thank You Letter?

Can You Write a Better Thank You Letter?

 

17 November 2026

 

By David Allen, Development for Conservation

 

Set aside an hour for making thank you phone calls this week.

 

It’s really cliché, but late November is time to reconsider how gratitude gets expressed to those who love us and those who care about us.

Take an objective look at your organization’s thank you messages – digital and paper both. Are you proud of them? Do they feel authentic and sincere, or just professional? Would you feel genuinely valued by the organization that sent them, or just “closed.” Gift given: thank you received,

At their most basic, thank you messages need to be professional. They need to communicate that the donor’s gift has been received and properly recorded. They need to carry the IRS disclaimer about no gifts or services being received in return.

But thank-you messages can do so much more than that. Can BE so much more than that.

How can we use thank you messages to engender loyalty? Improve renewals? Help members and donors feel engaged and valued? Like they are playing an important role in the success outcomes?

 

I believe that the nonprofit world is a competitive marketplace. I wrote several weeks ago that you are only one of her charities. (See She is Not One of Your Donors.) So, her experience of giving to your land trust is being compared, fairly or not, with her giving to other organizations.

Do you stack up? Or stick out?

 

Here are some ideas for sticking out (in a good way):

  • Think speed – Every day counts against you. Establish a 48-hour rule, but get acknowledgments out the same day or the day after the gift comes in if you possibly can. You can’t control the post office. In my neighborhood, a letter mailed on Monday might get across town by Friday. It might get there next week. Give yourself the best chance possible to say thank you before they forget they gave.
  • Think multi-channel – Yes, send a postcard, form email, or form letter right away. But also consider sending a separate card, leaving a separate phone message, assigning follow-up responsibility to a Board member or other volunteer, or remembering the gift in person if you plan to see them within a couple of weeks.
  • Think personal – If they also volunteer, if they came to the annual meeting, if they recently got married – mention these events in the gift acknowledgement. Show that you are writing to them, and let them know how their gift made you feel. Help them feel valued as a member of a valued organization.
  • Think telephone – Want to really stick out in their memory? Call them. Use a phone script for leaving a message, and have a short set of talking points to use if they answer the phone.

 

Everyone in your organization should participate in thanking members and donors. All Board members, all staff, interested volunteers – everyone can make phone calls or write thank you cards. And should. I know of a handful of land trust organizations whose Board directors make thank you calls. As a group, they tend to have impressive renewal and retention rates, and Board directors feel proud of their role as ambassadors.

Several use “gratitude events,” with everyone taking the day off from their normal duties and spending the day together writing cards and making phone calls. One organization, during COVID, got everyone on a ZOOM call. For 45 minutes they each put themselves on mute and made thank you phone calls to members and donors. (They left their video ON, so everyone could see everyone else calling donors.) After the time was up, they spent a last 15 minutes evaluating the experience.

 

Some things are hard to do. This isn’t hard. What will you do to express gratitude this Fall?

 

Cheers, and have a great week.

 

-da

 

PS: Your comments on these posts are welcomed and warmly requested. If you have not posted a comment before, or if you are using a new email address, please know that there may be a delay in seeing your posted comment. That’s my SPAM defense at work. I approve all comments as soon as I am able during the day.

Photo by Veronika Andrews courtesy of Pixabay.

 

 

Share this!
No Comments

Post A Comment